~ Welcome to my ~
Merry Day #6!
In the upcoming week...
I am going to review several needlework stands. I am the proud of owner of several different styles and all different brands of needlework stands. So I thought it would be helpful for those of you that are interested in knowing more about them and perhaps purchasing one (or two, or three, or four...) with your Santa bucks I'm sure you'll soon find in your stocking 😉
So without further ado...
here is day 1 of the grand parade of needlework stands.
*PLEASE NOTE* all of these stands that I will be sharing were purchased by me for the sole purpose of my own personal use in my needlework hobby. No company or entity, has given me anything (ever) for purpose of giving my "review". It is important to me that I give a review of whatever I am using that is honest, sincere and purchased by me for said use, with no smoke and mirrors and incentive to say nice things because they were given to me.
Also....
these are *my opinions* I have a right to them, I am not here to argue them, you may take them or leave them. If you don't like anything I do, say or share, please scroll on by and do not return. I do not have time in life for negative nellies and people wishing to pick an argument.
~ Thank you for understanding ~
(sad I have to utter such nonsense, but....I have come to learn in the last couple of years that there are people out there intent on bringing down - I only wish to build up.)
With that out of the way, let us proceed.
Day #1 ~ Needlework Stand Review ~
THE FANNY (SEAT) STAND by Hardwicke Manor
This is what the base looks like:
- This stand is not made for use on a table top (the base is not heavy enough) -
The stand is to be used by placing it under your "seat". I use mine in two different ways:
MY PERFERRED PLACEMENT:
I place it between my legs with it seated under either the right or left thigh (right behind the bend in my knee) until it is flush against the "seat" that you are sitting in as shown in the photos:
PLACEMENT #2:
Or you may use it in what I like to call "side saddle" and place it under the outside of either your right or left thigh, right behind the bend in the knee, until it is flush against the "seat" your are sitting in:
Now then, you get your hoop "head" or "hoop on a stick" and...
stick in in the hole of the base...
Turn the "screw" on the base to adjust the height of the hoop that is perfect for you. The screw is tightened at any height along the hoop stick (or neck).
This is what it looks like when you are ready to stitch:
The hoop is easily lifted up for easy ending of threads (see the butterfly screw in the neck of the hoop below) AND easily adjusted to any angle for your preferred stitching position:
This allows for two handed stitching. I prefer my left hand on top:
and my right hand underneath:
You may also purchase other "hoops on a stick" in other sizes (both smaller and larger):
Which allows for quick changes if you tire of one project in a stitching session
OR if you wish to have multiple projects on the go
OR if you have small projects and very large projects and just want a smaller or larger stitching area visible:
I have 3 different sizes of hoops on a stick, 6 inch, 8.5 in and 12 inch.
All of my hoop widths are 7/8 inch.
Why 7/8 inch? because it is wider and I feel allows a better "grip" on my fabric and I personally feel it makes less stress on the weave of my fabric thereby not making such severe hoop marks. (personal opinion there)
I wrap all of my hoops (on the inside hoop) with cotton twill tape.
why?
because twill tape allows a better grip on the stitching fabric AND it lessens hoop marks. I know some people also wrap the top hoop - I don't because I didn't feel like it made a difference as far as hoop marks go and it made it really thick and hard to close the screw on the hoop (just another personal opinion)
Wrapping your hoop + a wider (thicker) hoop = easy to get out hoop marks.
My preferred hoop sizes are:
the 6 inch and the 8.5 inch hoops on a stick. For me, I feel the 12 inch hoop is too big for the seat stand - it is gangly, awkward and frankly uncomfortable to stitch on.
Here is a comparison of my two favorite sizes: 6 inch (blue fabric) 8.5 inch (neutral fabric):
When I have two hoops going at once, I place the one not in use on a wall hook:
(yes I need to clean up and organize my magnetic board!)
While the other stays loaded on the stand and sits on the floor beside my stitching chair:
The designs in my hoops:
"It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas" by Shannon Christie Designs
and
"The Cookie Exchange" by Hands On Design "
I do not take my projects off the hoops while they are waiting to be stitched. I leave them loaded until they are finished - I have never had an issue with this practice - I just want to come in sit down and stitch, not have to fool around loading up projects.
PROS OF THE FANNY (SEAT) STAND:
1.) light weight
2.) easily transportable - the neck screws out of the base and the hoop on a stick folds flat. So if travelling - very compact
3.) easily adapted to your stitching preferences - up and down height + angle of stitching
4.) easy to have multiple projects on the go - if you so wish by the purchase of multiple hoops on a stick
5.) different sizes of hoops on a stick available for purchase means more stitching options to suit individual needs
6.) not very cost prohibitive - you will not sink a lot of money into this system
CONS OF THE FANNY (SEAT) STAND:
1.) can use it only as a seat stand, cannot use it any other way (for instance: on a table top)
2.) the brass screws on the hoops WILL strip over time, so the purchase of extra screws is a necessity over time
3.) hoop marks - no matter what you do there WILL be hoop marks, you can lessen their depth and make them easier to get out by wrapping your hoop, but there will be hoop marks - that does not bother me - but it may bother some.
MY PERSONAL THOUGHTS:
I find this stand one of my favorites - especially for travelling and taking to stitching events. I also like to use it for smaller projects. I like it because I can stitch with my feet up or down. I love it because it is light weight and I can use it with a blanket on my legs if I need to. I do not use it for large projects. I've used this stand now for 3 years and I really could not live without it.
*Seriously - this stand is in my top 3 personal favorites *
(at the end of these parade of stands I will rank my stands according to my preference)
WHY A STAND?:
For insight in case you don't have a stand and are wondering why I use one, or you are thinking about using one, I thought I'd share why I use a stand: I cannot stitch in hand, because I finish/craft/stitch every day making repetitive motions in my fingers, wrists, elbows and shoulders. 16 years ago I had severe elbow pain. I went to my doctor and he told me my stitching had to stop in order to not have pain in my hands/arms/shoulders. I had a repetitive motion inflammatory process going on, and he said the only way to fix it was to go to physical therapy and discontinue stitching. At that time I stitched one handed using a q-snap - I can stitch in hand, but I never have preferred that technique in stitching. Stitching is my hobby and in many ways - my way of life. I was not going to stop stitching. So I had to find a way to make stitching better for me. Using a stand either floor, lap or table top was the answer for me. It may not be for you.
I am going to be blunt again, so hold on to your socks....
taking a trip around blogs, social media, stitching online groups, YouTube video blogs about stitching (what some term "flosstube"), you will find that like any hobby their are "purists" and what some would term the "stitching police". I practice several hobbies, as you all know, and these sort of people exist in every hobby. They proceed telling people, in a very high handed way, things like: you don't need anything except a needle and thread - I stitch in hand and that is the best way, you don't need all those gadgets - I am sure you have seen such comments on threads. Then there is what I like to term the "cool" factor...its "cool" to stitch in hand, all the most respected, popular stitchers - stitch in hand. (They also only use linen and stitch on 40 count and higher linens of the finest brands with silk alone.)
Here is what I think:
I've never been a popular girl.
I am a free thinker. I value others real opinions and their own personal real life experiences, because I can always in some way find out something that may work better for me. I want to do my hobby in a way that I can do it every day without pain. I cannot stitch in hand. I am physically limited and cannot do it - per my medical doctor - in hand. That does not make me less of a stitcher, or one that isn't doing it the "correct" way or someone just wanting to "spend a lot of money" on paraphernalia that is unnecessary.
(YES, YES look around in group forums and you'll inevitably see a thread about this very subject and there will be a comment that people are blowing money buying "all the gadgets".)
PHOOEY!
Be a trendsetter and do what you want. March to the beat of your own drum in your own parade, and don't give a hoot what others think.
Stitch on aida, or evenweave, or linen of the finest quality, in whatever count, color and style that you desire!
Stitch in hand, or stitch using a hoop, q-snap, stand or frame! Stitch standing or sitting or standing on your head, heck you can even stitch in bed! Stitch on a train, in the toilet, in your car, in the market, stitch inside or outside, while you are swimming, on the beach, in the air - you can stitch ANYWHERE!
Don't use any gadgets, or use every single gadget ever put on the market! It is YOUR hobby! Do it like you want, just don't be discouraged to NOT do it!
DO WHAT EVER MAKES YOU HAPPY!
This is a hobby, and I have loved this hobby and have practiced it every day (I have never taken a "break" or went away to come back to stitching) for 40 years. 40 years of stitching - in my mind means, I have enough experience to have a credible opinion on helping others find ways that may help them to stitch more efficiently and in a way that works for them if they have questions or need help. That's all I want to do - help bring others to this craft, to this hobby, so that they may find the joy that I have found. No one, in any hobby should be made to feel doubt about their abilities, or their preferences. You can attain your stitching nirvana and STITCH HAPPY with whatever and however you choose. Stitching makes me who I am. I can assure you that I am going to doggone do whatever I can to make sure that I can do it every day until my last day here. It is my hope that in some small way, I inspire and empower others to embrace and love stitching as much as I do. That is my singular goal, and has been for years and years. To give content (and good solid content) freely on stitching, to inspire others. May it be so!
Until tomorrow....
Merry Day #6!
Merry Christmas!
All my love,
Vonna xxxx
You are the most real person I know! I love you!!!!!
ReplyDeleteThis is very helpful. Currently I have a floor stand for millennium frame on orde--there is a very long lead time (like 6-9 mons) Hope I am not disappointed
ReplyDeleteI'm so glad you are doing these! I'm considering a stand of some sort for a few reasons.. less stress on my arms and hands, less stress on my neck (my eyes are starting to require more help lol) and prolonging my stitching career. I really prefer to read honest opinions from folks who have used the products I'm researching fir a while, and aren't being compensated by anyone.
ReplyDeleteAs for your other comments on this hobby we love.. I almost jumped out of my seat and began applauding. I remember heated debates over white and antique white aida when that was all that was readily available. Even on the old AOL boards, there were those who considered themselves the "cross stitch police". (Sigh) They have accomplished something, though, they have given me a much deeper appreciation for all of the stitchers like you who are willing to share their knowledge, passion and experience to help others improve their stitching journey.
Blessings to you!
I'm so glad you are doing these! I'm considering a stand of some sort for a few reasons.. less stress on my arms and hands, less stress on my neck (my eyes are starting to require more help lol) and prolonging my stitching career. I really prefer to read honest opinions from folks who have used the products I'm researching fir a while, and aren't being compensated by anyone.
ReplyDeleteAs for your other comments on this hobby we love.. I almost jumped out of my seat and began applauding. I remember heated debates over white and antique white aida when that was all that was readily available. Even on the old AOL boards, there were those who considered themselves the "cross stitch police". (Sigh) They have accomplished something, though, they have given me a much deeper appreciation for all of the stitchers like you who are willing to share their knowledge, passion and experience to help others improve their stitching journey.
Blessings to you!
Love my Fanny Stand and those 2 smaller hoops, so versatile. Found everything said in Day 6 to be so very pertinent. I stitch mostly in a stand, but save my in-hand for hardanger (wrist issues). I have my very old "Grip-It" floor stand and sit-on stand, which my husband has 'fixed' for me to work just fine, I'm used to it and like to spend my stitching money on patterns, fibers, finishing material (thanks to you), and linens. It works, settles my soul, to me that is what it is all about. Thanks again Vonna for saying what needs to be said. You keep me motivated and learning.
ReplyDeleteI applaud you and I agree with you 1000% ! You are the most honest-to-goodness real person that gives your opinion honestly and allows others to do what they love as they want to do it! I have been stitching and sewing for 62+ years and God willing , will continue as long as I can. Thank you for your time and your knowledge. Love and hugs from Arizona
ReplyDeleteAmen, Vonna! Yes, you should do what works for you, and makes you happy. I am really looking forward to the rest of your stand posts. Some day, I will buy a really good stand. In the meantime, I like reading the perspectives of people who own more than 1 kind, to help me decide.
ReplyDeleteI don't usually comment, but had to today. I so agree with your philosophy of stitching...do what makes YOU happy and don't worry bout the naysayers. Needlework...or any hobby for that matter...is meant to be enjoyed, not feel like "work" or belittled by others. You go Vonna..keep on keeping on!!!
ReplyDeleteWhat a beautiful post! thank you! I don't know what I would do if I could not stitch. I believe that is literally when I would begin dying. I have been stitching for 60 years now.
ReplyDeleteVonna, I loved every word you spoke/wrote in the post, but especially from "I am going to be blunt... to the end". I am looking forward to your reviews and your shares. There will always be "police" in whatever craft/hobby, but what they don't realize (or maybe they do and can't help themselves) is that haughty attitude will drive people away from said craft/hobby. I think we should form the "uncool" girl's corner because I think there are more of us than of them. Thank you, Vonna!
ReplyDeleteThank you, thank you, thank you!!! I avoid the "police" discussions. (I show dogs, there's more than enough of that type of conversation there, some justified, most not.) I stitch to bring myself joy and plan to keep it that way.
ReplyDeleteLove your comments; love your blog! Thanks.
ReplyDeleteI love following you because you are a free thinker and do what works best for you. I love your style and that you share your whole thought process. Thanks for just being you.
ReplyDeleteI have a K's creation lapstand/tabletop stand that I use for the very same reason. I cannot stitch in hand or I get tendonitis.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the informative post!
ReplyDeleteVonna, many thanks for your interesting blog posts over the years. I have used a lap stand for many years, with various hoops, but also have used the stemmed hoops with a barrel clamp, that will attach to a table. Very versatile and easy to use when travelling. These are sold in the UK where I live, so I would guess they are available in the US, too. Happy Christmas!
ReplyDeleteVonna, I am really enjoying your December blog entries. You are a blessing to your readers. This information about stands, etc. is just invaluable to a returning stitcher. I did give it up in the 90s to go into quilting. I guess I can only handle one thing at a time…and that one not very well! But you are a born teacher and I just thank you so very much for your detailed instruction and your honesty. I am reading and enjoying every blog entry! Carol in Texas
ReplyDeleteThank you for stating it like it is 'out there' in the stitching world! I agree 100% - you can learn from the 'purists' but in the end be yourself; do what's right, comfortable for oneself. Don't let anyone put down you or your methods. If they do, walk away. I love my stand just as you do. Thanks for doing the reviews and sharing your experiences. I always learn something new reading your blogs. Wishing you and yours a joyous festive season!
ReplyDeleteLove your comments about this being a hobby and doing it to suit you. I have been put down several times in groups because I only stitch on Aida. It used to bother me but I have decided that is what makes me happy and I think my projects look just as good to me as those stitched on linen or evenweave.
ReplyDeleteAmen! Your sentences on stitching wherever you want instantly reminded me of the Dr Seuss book Fox in Sox, that I’ve been reading with my granddaughter! Stitch in whatever way suits you as long as you’re stitching!
ReplyDeleteLove your review!! I am getting one of these fanny frames for Christmas, and I was excited to see this review about it today and that it works so well for you. I think it will work for me too. I am like you--I do what works for me regardless of what others say. I can stitch in hand--I did for many years--I choose not to most of the time because I think my stitching looks better when I stitch in a hoop, q snap, scroll rod, etc. And give me ALL the gadgets and tools! Lol!! But definitely to each their own. Now I am off to read the other blog posts I have missed.... Thank you! I hope you and your family have a blessed Christmas!
ReplyDelete